Court rules Mary Ng’ethe must refund Sh13m amid NCC cemetery land scandal; lawyer Alphonse Mutinda refuses to refund Sh25.9m
The Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (EACC) has obtained court orders mandating a former official of the Nairobi City Council to reimburse Ksh13 million associated with the contentious Ksh283 million cemetery land scandal. The EACC has obtained court orders mandating a former official of the Nairobi City Council to reimburse Ksh13 million associated with the contentious Ksh283 million cemetery land scandal.
In a statement released on Thursday, March 26, the EACC indicated that the funds were retrieved from Mary Ng’ethe, who formerly held the position of Chairperson of the Technical Evaluation Committee.
"The funds were retrieved from Ms. Mary Ng’ethe, who held the position of Chairperson of the Technical Evaluation Committee. She received the funds as a kickback for her involvement in facilitating the fraudulent scheme," the statement noted.
As per the EACC, a ruling issued by Justice Benjamin Musyoki of the Anti-Corruption and Economic Crimes Court identified Ng’ethe as a key player in the scandal, holding her directly accountable for manipulating the procurement process.
"In a judgment delivered on March 24, 2026, Justice Benjamin Musyoki of the Anti-Corruption and Economic Crimes Court determined that Ng’ethe was pivotal to the transaction. The court concluded that she orchestrated and directed the flawed procurement process and that the funds she received were a reward for her participation," the statement further elaborated.
However, while the EACC continues its commendable efforts, residents of Nairobi are questioning why individuals previously identified as having also profited from the same scandal have not returned the funds.
One notable case involves Lawyer Mutinda Alphonce, whom the High Court in Nairobi instructed to refund Sh25.9 million that he received from the fraudulent sale of land designated for a public cemetery.
This amount was part of a larger Sh283.2 million transaction that occurred in 2008-2009, during which the now-defunct Nairobi City Council acquired land for a cemetery that was subsequently deemed unsuitable. Milimani Judge Esther Maina ordered Mutinda to repay the Sh25.9 million, along with interest dating back to 2009, when he received it.
The Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (EACC) demonstrated that Mutinda acted on behalf of the vendor and accepted the funds, fully aware that the procurement process had been compromised, with the land being sold at an inflated price. It is regrettable that Mutinda has not reimbursed the amount as mandated by the court.

Comments
Post a Comment